Guardian Unlimited
Go to:  
Guardian Unlimited PoliticsSpecial Reports
Home Ask Aristotle Whitehall Parliament Polls Backbencher MP’s surgery
Talk Special reports Thinktanks Beyond Westminster Links Comment This week

David Kelly

Ask Aristotle Politics database
Find out about your MP
Enter postcode or place:
 
Enter person:
 
How to use Aristotle
Archive search
 
Advanced search

In this section
Letters: What I said

Letters: unanswered questions over Dr Kelly's death

Who's in charge of the BBC?

Richard Eyre: Nobody does it better

Letters: Fantasists and Dr Kelly

Crispin Black: Blair's claim is incredible

Letters: Medical evidence does not support suicide by Kelly

Ex-officer points to failings on 45-minute claim

Kelly given top place in news poll

Campbell gets a savaging



Special report: David Kelly


4pm


UN man tells of Kelly prophesy

Ciar Byrne and Matthew Tempest
Thursday August 21, 2003


David Kelly
Kelly: made remark months before meeting Gilligan
 
David Kelly told a senior diplomat in February that if Iraq was invaded he would "probably be found dead in the woods", the Hutton inquiry heard today.

The weapons inspector, who is believed to have committed suicide after being named as the source of a highly controversial BBC story, made the prophetic comment months before the storm over his conversation with the reporter Andrew Gilligan broke.

David Broucher, a permanent representative on the convention on UN disarmament in Geneva, told the inquiry how he met the weapons inspector earlier this year.

Mr Broucher said that at the time he had taken Dr Kelly's comment to be a throwaway remark designed to imply the Iraqis could take their revenge on him.

But he said that with hindsight he realised Dr Kelly "may have been thinking along different lines" in the light of his apparent suicide last month, when Dr Kelly was found dead in woods near his Oxfordshire home.

Mr Broucher said he had met Dr Kelly just once, in Geneva on February 27, when they discussed Iraq's compliance or non-compliance with the convention on biological weapons.

"As Dr Kelly was leaving, I said to him what will happen if Iraq is invaded," Mr Broucher told the inquiry.

"And his reply was - which I took at the time to be a throwaway remark - 'I will probably be found dead in the woods'."

Mr Broucher said he had gathered from their conversation that Dr Kelly felt he was being put in a "morally ambiguous position" because he was telling Iraqi contacts they had nothing to fear if they co-operated with UN weapons inspections.

He emailed Patrick Lamb, the deputy head of the Foreign Office's counter-proliferation unit, warning that Dr Kelly had said the Iraqis were "inveterate keepers of written files - something they have learned from us".

Telling the inquiry how he heard of Dr Kelly's death on Swiss TV, he said: "It was not until I became aware of the circumstances of his death I realised the significance of this remark that he made to me."

Mr Broucher said Dr Kelly told him he was in contact with senior Iraqis whom he had "urged" to give up any remaining biological weapons.

He continued: "He [Kelly] believed that the invasion might go ahead anyway, and this puts him in a morally ambiguous position".

Dr Kelly had told Mr Broucher that the Iraqi were unwilling to fully disarm because "if they revealed too much about their state of readiness, this might increase the risk of being attacked."

Concluding his evidence, Mr Broucher said he thought Dr Kelly had been implying the Iraqis would take revenge on him - "something that did not seem fanciful then. I now realise he may have been thinking on different lines."

· To contact the MediaGuardian newsdesk email editor@mediaguardian.co.uk or phone 020 7239 9857

 Special reports
The media and Hutton
Iraq dossier affair
The Hutton inquiry
Politics and David Kelly

 Timelines
21.08.2003: Dossier affair at a glance
20.08.2003: Creation of the dossier
18.08.2003: How MoD came to confirm Kelly's name
19.08.2003: The evolution of the Iraq dossier
David Kelly: how the tragedy unfolded
The Gilligan affair: a chronology of events

 Who's who in the Hutton inquiry
15.08.2003: Witnesses week two
Witnesses week one
19.08.2003: Profiles: Blair's inner circle

 The inquiry so far
21.08.2003: Day seven summary
20.08.2003: Day six summary
19.08.2003: Day five summary
15.08.2003: Day four summary
14.08.2003: Day three summary
12.08.2003: Day two summary
Day one summary

 Document archive
Emails, statements, interview notes - all the key evidence

 Day eight: Thursday August 21
21.08.2003: It was easy to identify Kelly, says journalist
21.08.2003: Kelly said Gilligan report was 'bullshit', inquiry told
21.08.2003: Hoon: Don't ask Kelly about WMD
21.08.2003: Channel 4 to make Kelly docu-drama
21.08.2003: Observer man to face inquiry
21.08.2003: FAC head to face Hutton inquiry

 Day seven: Wednesday August 20
20.08.2003: Campbell plotted Kelly press leak
20.08.2003: MoD man points finger at Blair
20.08.2003: 'Outing' of Kelly sparked Whitehall panic
20.08.2003: Hoon 'feared cover-up charge'
20.08.2003: Did Gilligan blow Kelly's cover?
20.08.2003: Backroom players in Hutton spotlight

 Day six: Tuesday August 19
20.08.2003: Campbell puts Hoon in frame on day of drama
20.08.2003: Campbell saw naming of Kelly as way to prove his case
19.08.2003: Campbell stands firm on 45-minute claim
20.08.2003: 'No input, output or influence'
19.08.2003: Birt backed Campbell in BBC row
20.08.2003: Gilligan 'tried to influence questions by MPs'
19.08.2003: Gilligan tried to prompt Kelly to voice fears
19.08.2003: Campbell denies briefing press
19.08.2003: Campbell: my fears over BBC story
19.08.2003: Spotlight falls on Campbell
20.08.2003: British Richelieu takes his place in history

 Day five: Monday August 18
19.08.2003: No 10 knew: Iraq no threat
19.08.2003: 'Was Dr Kelly playing or played with?'
19.08.2003: BBC failed to give Hoon right of reply
19.08.2003: Picture emerges of nerves in the No 10 den
18.08.2003: Downing Street played 'chicken' with BBC
18.08.2003: BBC 'drove speculation on Gilligan's source'
18.08.2003: Blair and Campbell involved
18.08.2003: Campbell 'pro-active' over naming of Kelly
18.08.2003: FT man was first to put Kelly's name to MoD
18.08.2003: Downing Street helped 'out' Dr Kelly
18.08.2003: MoD advice to press officers
18.08.2003: NUJ: Hutton inquiry endangers privacy
18.08.2003: Inquiry to make evidence public
18.08.2003: Emails show Gilligan's frustration at No 10
19.08.2003: Leader: Campbell's kingdom
19.08.2003: Marina Hyde: Pure West Wing
18.08.2003: Matt Wells: It's journalism that's on trial
18.08.2003: Roy Greenslade: Off the fence

 Friday August 15
15.08.2003: Campbell to take witness stand on Tuesday
15.08.2003: Dates and times of witnesses: August 18-21 2003

 Day four: Thursday August 14
15.08.2003: Kelly was 'weapon' in war against BBC
15.08.2003: Second source 'troubled' by dossier claims
15.08.2003: BBC pays for Watts' lawyers
15.08.2003: How trail of evidence reached No 10
14.08.2003: Final dossier used 'harder' language
14.08.2003: Kelly 'under huge pressure' in hours before death
14.08.2003: Hoon was asked not to put Kelly on 'trial'
14.08.2003: Kelly was 'composed' despite MoD pressure
14.08.2003: Kelly read 'the riot act'
14.08.2003: Coroner: cuts to wrist killed Kelly
14.08.2003: Secret document 'leaked' to Gilligan
14.08.2003: BBC boss praises Gilligan for not toeing MoD line

 Day three: Wednesday August 13
14.08.2003: Document treasure trove reveals key clues
14.08.2003: Letter reveals Kelly's media links
14.08.2003: War of words split BBC
14.08.2003: Unity crumbles in the spotlight - but will the corporation recover?
13.08.2003: Today editor 'called Campbell bonkers'
13.08.2003: Sambrook's actions were 'driven by duty'
13.08.2003: Watts: 'BBC tried to mould my story'
13.08.2003: Kelly blamed 'someone' at No 10
13.08.2003: Watts: 'Kelly did not blame Campbell'
13.08.2003: Watts spoke to Kelly as Campbell gave evidence

 Day two: Tuesday August 12
13.08.2003: Murdoch papers lambast BBC over Kelly affair
13.08.2003: BBC governors were split over Today report
13.08.2003: BBC's public stance hid doubts on Gilligan
13.08.2003: A tale of flaws, evasion and spin unfolds
13.08.2003: How governors put aside fears to back Gilligan
13.08.2003: Reporter's three takes on a story still far from clarity
12.08.2003: Campbell claim was 'gossipy aside'
12.08.2003: Gilligan changed story for MPs
12.08.2003: Gilligan's Mail on Sunday article was not vetted
12.08.2003: Gilligan 'millstone' worried BBC
12.08.2003: Gilligan claims reopen controversy
12.08.2003: Gilligan did not have 'full notes'

 Day one: Monday August 11
11.08.2003: Hutton inquiry at a glance: day one
12.08.2003: Iraq dossier blow for Blair
12.08.2003: Protests as documents held back
12.08.2003: A brilliant scientist showered with praise, but not pay
11.08.2003: Kelly email raised concerns over spin
11.08.2003: MoD man reveals dossier 'disquiet'
11.08.2003: Foreign Office and MoD opinions differ over Kelly
11.08.2003: MoD: Kelly was not named 'gratuitously'
11.08.2003: Kelly was in 'normal' frame of mind days before his death

 Run-up to the Hutton inquiry
11.08.2003: Legal eagles set for Kelly inquiry
11.08.2003: Senior counsel seen as low-key but tough
11.08.2003: Careers on the line as hearings get under way
11.08.2003: Test of Blair's trust begins
Lord Hutton's statement about the inquiry

 Andrew Gilligan's original Today broadcast
The Iraq dosser report that sparked the row

 Useful link
Hutton inquiry website




Printable version | Send it to a friend | Save story



UP

Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2004